Ok, so this is going to be similar to the twin/triplet etc. games going on except instead of choosing one name then coming up with three others you'll keep your favorite (or least hated) as-is, change one of the others, then only make two of your own new choices.

Example:
Beginning names-
Kaity Valentine, Kelsey Virginia, Krimson Valerie, and Kody Veronica

I keep- Kelsey Virginia
Change- Kaity Valentine -to- Katherine Valentina
Then choose- Kolby Vaughn and Kyson Victor
New names-
Kelsey Virginia, Katherine Valentine, Kolby Vaughn, and Kyson Victor

Get the point? Okay, now it's your turn.

Let's start with-
Chelsea Noelle, Crimson Rose, Christian Ryder, and Colton Michael

I was going to play but I don't understand. Maybe someone else gets it....

Chelsea Noelle, Crimson Rose, Christian Ryder, and Colton Michael

I keep- Chelsea Noelle
I change- Crimson rose to Charity rose
My two- Christopher ray and channing Mitchel

Hope thats what you were after hehe

Keep: Chelsea Noelle
Change: Charity Rose back to Crimson Rose (can I do that? I really like Crimson!)
2 New: Tannen Nicholas & Thomas Kyle

keep: Tannen Nicholas
change: Chelsea Noelle to Charlotte Noelle
2 new: Ari Nixon and Matilda Nadine

keep: Tannen Nicholas

change: Charlotte noelle to Chloe Anjolie

2 new: Mykayla James and Hannah Isabella

I hope id did that right?