Ami - I've never heard that song, but I have John Mayers voice, so... I've never even thought of father daughter songs.

I probably wont do it with my dad.
Kristen Anne - Haha, my mom doesnt remember her first dance song either.
I dont like that "kissing you" song. Her voice grates on my nerves.
I love "bring it on home to me" though, but it doesnt sound like a wedding song.
kdel - Congrats!
I think I'd kinda like Heaven by Bryan Adams. I've always loved it, and its so sweet.